"State
of the Unions: A Century of American Labor" by Nelson Lichtenstein. 2002.
336 pages. $ 29.95.
Noted labor historian Lichtenstein examines the key
question of what has happened to our understanding of the vital importance of
labor to social justice.
For most of the 20th century, "the labor
question" - as it was put in the early 1900s - was widely seen as a burning
issue. This persisted through the uprisings of workers and the unemployed and
government encouragement for unions in the 1930s, through the post World War II
period and into the 1950s.
Organized labor continued to grow into the
'50s and started its long decline as a proportion of the work force in the 60s.
Lichtenstein sees the seeds of defeat planted in the employer campaign to counter
labor solidarity that passed the Taft-Hartley Act of 1947.
In the years
that followed, unions maintained their strength but gradually divorced themselves
from the wider movement for social change. Many gained impressive contractual
health, welfare and pension benefits - which cooled their passion for national
gains for everyone.
Only the most progressive unions participated in
the civil rights movement - including AFSCME, DC 37's national union - while some
defended racist hiring practices.
The public began to see unions as a
special interest and with the Teamster investigations of the late '50s, a sometimes
corrupt one. By the time Ronald Reagan broke the Air Controllers strike in the
early 1980s, the unions were isolated, setting the stage for a new onslaught in
which Southern tactics of union busting were employed nationwide.
Today,
unions make up less than 10 percent of the non-public sector work force - down
from one-third in the 1950s. It's no accident that real wages have stagnated and
income equality has grown during this same period.
Lichtenstein assesses
the new leadership of the AFL-CIO, which has fought to reverse the long historical
trend he has described. They have reached out to the civil rights, immigrant,
student, academic, left and other formerly alienated communities. They have nurtured
new organizing and established union rights among today's civil rights struggles.
These efforts have gone a long way to change labor's image and even to halt its
decline, but under the Clinton and Bush administrations the needed growth spurt
has not materialized.
Lichtenstein does not have all the answers, but
he has certainly posed the right questions to advance the discussion of the state
of the unions and what has to be done.
Ken Nash
DC 37 Ed. Fund Library,
Room 211